ciscocrank
28 posts

my question is " comparing between layer 3 switch which is also support routing protocol with general router " for example how can I compare between cisco 3750 switch and router 2900 series in

1- speed 2- routing 3- QOS 4- cost

thank you

alhafoudh
3 posts

read about CEF

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cisco_Express_Forwarding

scarface
23 posts

Router: NAT, NBAR (QoS), serial and other interface, low number of interfaces, IPSec

Switch: more interfaces, better performance

pr0d16y
3 posts

Modern switches generally have the same capabilities as routers (if you have the right image), they are just much faster and much more expensive and normally only do ethernet.

ciscocrank
28 posts

thanks for all

as I see , router support expansion module for security , voice , wan ...,advance routing . multilayer switch support fast internal routing , several interfaces I think it has limited feature related with layer 3 like ACLs , qos .

laith43d
109 posts

MLS has a very limited layer 3 capabilities, it does not have any support for the WAN interfaces and protocols, BGP, very limited QoS, and generally routing capabilities. You can use the MLS for LAN switching and routing, however if you have huge network with big routing tables, you will not be able to use MLS since it has less capabilities than routers.

curtwilson
4 posts

Typically you are going to want a router at your network edge to the Internet because of its better support for WAN technologies. Layer 3 switches are nice for core and distribution layers of your network to route traffic between VLANs. Layer 3 switches typically have more interfaces than routers. Layer 3 switches allow you to have both switch-port interfaces and have routing enabled all in one device, whereas routers only have routing interfaces and can only be configured with one interface per network subnet. For example, you cannot have 2 interfaces in a router belong to the same network subnet.

ciscocrank
28 posts

I undestand and thanks for all , but what about Catalyst 6500 cisco define this device as switch (multilayer core switch ) and when you looking in data sheet you see it is support WAN module and interfaces , also support rich of QOS features , I agree with (pr0d16y )

pr0d16y
3 posts

it depends on the switch. if you want a switch that supports different physical WAN technologies you need a cat6500 - they're pretty flexible and powerful enough for most tasks.

However you can run BGP on a 3750 if you want to and can pay for the neccessary IOS..

Viewing 1 - 9 of 9

  • 1